Clinical practice guidelines (CPG) can be defined as systematically developed recommendations and related content obtained by reviewing scientific evidence, which help healthcare providers make decisions. CPG is one of the most powerful tools that helps clinicians make evidence-based decisions in practice. Methodologies in areas essential for CPG development, such as for systematic review, risk of bias (ROB) assessment, adaptation, and the GRADE (Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluations, are rapidly developing. Therefore, they must be well-understood and applied to evidence-based CPG development. In this regard, it is necessary to learn about the updates and changed in the methodologies for CPG development. This manuscript covers the following CPG development methodologies: (1) main principles of CPG, (2) managing conflict of interest, (3) considering patient value and preference, (4) determination of key questions, (5) ROB assessment, (6) adaptation, (7) rapid guideline development, (8) living guideline development, and (9) GIN-McMaster Guideline Development Checklist.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Guidelines addressing Motor Neurone Disease (MND): a scoping review Cindy Stern, Ines Semendric, Nipun Shrestha, Jay Beasley-Hall, Sabira Hasanoff, Timothy Barker, Danielle Pollock, Camille Schubert, Lynne Giles, Steve Vucic, Tracy Merlin, Zachary Munn Neurodegenerative Disease Management.2026; 16(5): 603. CrossRef
Identification of Potentially Inappropriate Medications for Adults Below 65 Years: Protocol for a Modified Delphi Study Eva Filosa, Nicole Schönenberger, Utibe R Essien, Camille Gagnon, Danijela Gnjidic, Lisa Kouladjian O’Donnell, Elizabeth Manias, Lisa M McCarthy, Frank Moriarty, Jérôme Nguyen-Soenen, Sion Scott, Michael A Steinman, Petra A Thürmann, Marnie Goodwin Wilson JMIR Research Protocols.2026; 15: e92082. CrossRef
A Survey of Korean Medicine Doctors’ Recognition of the Development of Korean Medicine Clinical Practice Guidelines for Prostate Cancer Sang-jin Lee, Dong-hyeon Kim, Su-hyon Kim, So-jeong Wi, Jong-sung Park, Byung-cheol Lee, Seon-mi Shin, So-jung Park The Journal of Internal Korean Medicine.2026; 47(3): 403. CrossRef
A longitudinal analysis of published clinical practice guidelines and their effect on disease burden Xialei Li, Dannya Estau, Xiaoru Huang, Fuhua Deng, Xuening Liu, Xinghui Li, Jinfeng Gao, Zijian Li Nature Communications.2026;[Epub] CrossRef
Key quality considerations for advancing quality appraisal for living practice guidelines: a scoping review Madison McGuire, Alexandria Bennett, Niyati Patwa, Skyler Gauthier, Damilola Adedunye, Aniqa Tahsin, Nicole Shaver, Alexandra Bodnaruc, Tari Turner, Ivan D. Florez, Melissa Brouwers Journal of Clinical Epidemiology.2026; 200: 112485. CrossRef
Nephrologists’ perception of the French national guidelines in nephrology Latame Komla Adoli, Cécile Vigneau, Arnaud Campeon, Cécile Couchoud, Valérie Chatelet, Thierry Lobbedez, Eric Daugas, Florian Bayer, Elsa Vabret, Jean-Philippe Jais, Sahar Bayat-Makoei Scientific Reports.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
RoBANS 2: A Revised Risk of Bias Assessment Tool for Nonrandomized Studies of Interventions Hyun-Ju Seo, Soo Young Kim, Yoon Jae Lee, Ji-Eun Park Korean Journal of Family Medicine.2023; 44(5): 249. CrossRef
Association between Conflicts of Interest Disclosure and Quality of Clinical Practice Guidelines in Japan: A Meta-Epidemiological Study Norio Yamamoto, Akihiko Ozaki, Shunsuke Taito, Takashi Ariie, Hidehiro Someko, Hiroaki Saito, Tetsuya Tanimoto, Yuki Kataoka Journal of Personalized Medicine.2023; 13(12): 1722. CrossRef
Background : Family practice academic dissertations are the product of family practice research in the school of medicine. This paper was intended to evaluate the status of family practice academic dissertations, analyze the basic data and suggest directions for family practice research in the school of medicine.
Methods : The total number of masters' and doctoral dissertations from 1992 to February, 2005 was 124. of those, 120 were collected. They were analyzed in terms of research area, subjects, collected data, methodology, and statistical methods.
Results : In terms of research area, health promotion/ disease prevention was the most common (42.5%). For study subjects, out-patients and in-hospital patients were the most prevalent (38.0%), followed by health promotion center visitors and community residents (28.7%). When it came to research methodology, analytic study was the most common by a wide margin (70.8%). Among analytic studies, cross-sectional studies were the most frequent, followed by case-control studies and cohort studies. The most commonly-used data were medical records and questionnaires.
Conclusion : Many advances have been made in research methodology and academic dissertation numbers since 1992. Many research topics, however, were not relevant to primary care. Much research was done in general hospital instead of primary-care facilities. These results must improve in the future.
Background : Research is essential for the development of family medicine as a professional field in primary care, Since information is available through the articles in the Journals of Family Medicine which contain subjects such as disease mechanism, pathophysiology, drug or new treatment method, and it is necessary to evaluate the contribution of recent researches in this field. The paper is intended to evaluate the current status of the quality of papers published in the Journal of the Korea Academy of Family Medicine (below JKAFM) and provide statistical data & direction of studies in the future.
Methods : 1218 articles in 185 editions of JKAFM were analyzed among 188 editions published from Nov.1980 to Dec. 1996. The papers were classified into Case Report, Original Article, Review Article by the type of papers, and then categorized into descriptive studies, analytic studies, and clinical trials by its methodology. In each category, the papers were stratified by the topic. Also, the analysis was conducted according to the authors, research subjects, sampling methods and the statistical methods, and observed the changes each year through 1980s to 1990s.
Results : The portion of original articles has increased from 18.6% in 1980s to 73.9% in 1990s. In terms of research methodology, the portions of analytical studies and clinical trials occupy 28.8% and 2.1% in 1990's respectively, compared with those of 1.8% and 0.6% in 1980's. When the papers were stratified by study topics, topics on family medicine showed the highest of 34.9% of the total. According to the detailed stratification, the principle of family medicine recorded 24.2%. In terms of sampling method, 89% and above was from the clinical data when current data were used, and 69.1% was by questionnaires when the data were newly collected. The most of the study subjects were outpatients of family medicine departments. The portion of papers in which the statistical analysis was not included was 29.9% in 1980s which decreased to 15.7% in 1990s. In terms of the statistical analysis methodology, the Chi-square test was the most frequently used(26.2%), followed by Descriptive(19.6%), t-test(18.2%) and ANOVA(8.7%) were the next.
Conclusion : The academic performance of family medicine can be most effectively measured by the analysis of the journals on family medicine. According to the analysis, the papers based on clinical activity is increasing in recent years with substantial contribution, which means that the field of family medicine has found its own position in medical science and is developing actively. In terms of study methodology, the portion of analysis study is getting larger, and the various method are being tried. The application of statistical methods is being developed in its quality and quantity. It should be noted that research on family medicine should provide the basis for new knowledge and promote public health by the integrated and intensive efforts.